Small Wars Journal

Fixing the Problem: Integrating Virtue Ethics into U.S. Special Operations Forces Selection, Education, and Training

Fri, 02/07/2020 - 10:05am

Fixing the Problem: Integrating Virtue Ethics into U.S. Special Operations Forces Selection, Education, and Training

Benjamin Ordiway

Background

“A survey of allegations of serious misconduct across our formations over the last year indicate[s] that [United States Special Operations Command] USSOCOM faces a deeper challenge of a disordered view of the team and the individual in our SOF culture.”

    —General Raymond Thomas, Former Commander of USSOCOM, December 13, 2018[i]

“We have a problem.”

 —Rear Admiral Colin Green, Naval Special Warfare Commander July 25, 2019[ii]

“. . . this force does not have a systemic ethics problem.”    

           —General Richard Clarke, Current Commander of USSOCOM January 28, 2020[iii]

In The Story of Civilization, Volume III, philosopher and historian Will Durant warns, “A great civilization is not conquered from without until it has destroyed itself within.”[iv] Just as elevation is often associated with a position of tactical advantage in combat, the moral-ethical[v] high ground is key terrain in the defense of our civilization; when internal actors surrender the moral-ethical high ground, our adversary’s work is done for them. Every minute spent dealing with the consequences of moral-ethical breaches cedes a contour-line of respect and creates a widening window of opportunity for those who seek the United States’ capitulation as a global power and leader. Special Operations Forces (SOF), which fall under United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM), are the sentries entrusted with guarding this moral-ethical high ground across the continents.

SOF teams, though small in number, are designed to achieve outsized effects in support of strategic political and military objectives while in hostile or politically sensitive environments.[vi] Whether coordinating humanitarian assistance projects in the Balkans, enhancing counter-terrorism capabilities from Burkina Faso to Colombia, or targeting Islamic State (ISIS) fighters in Syria, SOF are persistently engaged as frontline emissaries of the United States. To this end, all SOF undergo a multi-week selection process and receive specialized training, which contributes to the development of unique and rich unit cultures.[vii] A sample of SOF unit mottos describe teams that are called to be “quiet professionals”[viii] (Special Forces), “always faithful, always forward”[ix] (Marine Raiders), and “warrior-diplomats”[x] (Civil Affairs). But what happens when the actions of a few servicemembers are neither quiet nor professional, causing senior political and military leaders to lose faith in the character and abilities of those forward? From war crimes, to drug trafficking, to murdering colleagues, a web-search of special operations moral-ethical issues returns plenty of front-page material. May of 2019 was an especially difficult month for USSOCOM’s reputation. In the span of thirty days, the military sentenced two Green Berets to nine years in prison for drug trafficking,[xi]and a Navy SEAL and a Marine Raider pleaded guilty to negligent homicide in the 2017 death of an Army Special Forces Soldier. Two months later, the Navy convicted a SEAL for posing in a photo with the corpse of an ISIS fighter.[xii] 

As the number of incidents grows, so does the outcry. Unfortunately, the response is becoming predictable. Congressionally-directed ethics reviews risk becoming commonplace in the National Defense Authorization Acts,[xiii] and memorandums from USSOCOM’s highest levels perennially call for cultural introspection across SOF.[xiv] Nevertheless, the findings of the recent ethics and culture review maintain a drumbeat that there is not a systemic ethics problem.[xv] As the report would have it, Congress and the public are encouraged to believe that the headlines are owed to the actions of a few bad apples. Should we expect and accept these spoiled fruits as an inevitable consequence of a strained force facing deployment after deployment?

Introduction

In August 2019, USSOCOM began a comprehensive review of SOF culture and ethics, which, at the lowest level, entailed a small group discussion with one’s peers facilitated by a review team. Additionally, every subordinate command within USSOCOM discussed ethics with the rank and file.[xvi] Upon hearing the details of the recent SOF moral-ethical breakdowns, many in the audience essentially asked, “what were they thinking?” as opposed to the metacognitive question, “how were they thinking?” Alarmingly, some even challenged the fairness of questioning the behaviors of those on ethics-trial, claiming that those in air-conditioned offices are committing the fundamental attribution error by assigning blame to a character flaw rather than the power of the situation. [xvii] Worse yet, others complained that an afternoon was spent unproductively discussing the acts of a “few bad apples,” further opining that the nature of SOF work is inherently “gray,” and that the media and Congress tend to overreact. Cynicism is more common than many would care to admit. It seems to dispose of personal responsibility and an individual’s moral agency, while also disregarding the warning signs that our status within the profession of arms faces an existential threat. A question left unaddressed during both events was, did USSOCOM select, educate, and train SOF for the correct type of moral-ethical thinking to prevent these situations?

When deployed, a SOF team’s high operational tempo, its embedment in a foreign culture—each with unique values, beliefs, norms, and temptations—and isolation from its higher command present unique challenges to SOF. These conditions yield fertile soil for situationism to take root. Situationism is the idea that situational factors (e.g., the actor’s stress level, sense of urgency, amount of social pressure, and the proximity of an authority figure),[xviii] determine how people act, significantly more so than character traits.[xix] While few dispute that a situation, alternatively referred to as the environment, does not contribute to a subject’s behavior, some ultimately say character traits are minimally important or that there is no such thing as character altogether.[xx] A middle way adopted by many in the field of moral psychology, known as interactionism, combines elements of situationism and trait theory. Many outside of the field of moral psychology would take interactionism—the idea that both situations and character traits affect our actions—to be common sense.[xxi] Interactionism forms the golden mean between the two extremes of trait theory and situationism theory by incorporating an actor’s character traits and the external environmental factors when explaining behavior.[xxii] What, then, should leaders focus on when assessing and selecting future special operations service members if aiming to deploy individuals and teams that will conduct themselves and their missions in morally and ethically appropriate ways? SOF leaders should pay heed to the saying “prepare the child for the road and not the road for the child.” Given that it is impossible to predict every situation or environmental factor those in SOF will face, the only practical and morally responsible choice is to focus on developing character—what some call virtue—to guide thinking and behavior.

Thesis

I propose that the best prevention of SOF moral-ethical transgressions is a systemic inoculation against situational influences. This can be achieved by raising selection standards and by educating and training personnel to think, decide, and act according to a virtue ethics framework. SOF leaders should expand existing selection criteria to include tests for moral and adult development. Once selected, units should steep individuals in a virtue ethics-based education before deployment. Finally, SOF unit leaders should incorporate moral virtue ethics tenants into field training to develop excellence in the exercise of moral-ethical judgment. These measures will increase individual resilience against the situational influences SOF personnel contest with at home and abroad, ensuring SOF mottos ring truer than regrettable headlines. 

SOF Selection

“The great challenge of a military profession in an increasingly pluralistic society is that we now have people coming into the profession who have far different and wide-ranging personal moralities than the institutional ethos.”

     —Colonel (Retired) Don Snider[xxiii]

SOF selection generally focuses on physical and cognitive abilities, personality compatibility deemed appropriate for mission success, and psychopathological issues.[xxiv] What goes unmeasured, at least formally, is an aspirant’s moral and adult development. Such screening would assist SOF commanders in knowing that all personnel in their formation demonstrated a moral foundation which could be reinforced through education and training to support institutional ethics. While additional testing may reduce the available pool of viable SOF candidates during selection, it need not. Instead, if a candidate scores on the lower range of moral and adult development, the assessors could flag the candidate’s file to inform future team placement, assuming the candidate passes the rest of the assessment and selection phase.

Two theories SOF assessors might rely on during the assessment and selection phase are Lawrence Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development and Robert Kegan’s Theory of the Evolution of Consciousness. Assessors could apply these theories through one-on-one interviews, through essays dealing with practical moral-ethical dilemmas based on vignettes from former and current SOF personnel, and through focused observation of an individual’s behavior in group settings with an eye toward their moral-ethical decision making. Additionally, SOF selection should incorporate these theories into tailored scenarios where individual SOF candidates may take a moral-ethical stand without being acutely aware of what is being evaluated. Finally, SOF candidates should be evaluated for incongruences between their individual behavior and behavior within a group setting with respect to instances where an assessment and selection event poses a moral-ethical question. A significant deviation between behaviors may illuminate areas of concern, such as a willingness to compromise a moral-ethical principle when exposed to the pressures of group conformity.

Lawrence Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development

Lawrence Kohlberg, expanding on the work of developmental psychologist Jean Piaget,[xxv] developed a three-level model of moral development spanning pre-conventional to post-conventional moral reasoning. Kohlberg further divides each level into two stages of increasingly complex types of reasoning. Finally, each level corresponds with an age range. [xxvi]

Pre-conventional morality encompasses the kind of moral reasoning found in preadolescents. In stage one, what is deemed right is obedience to an authority figure, and what is wrong is what that authority decides to punish. In stage two, moral reasoning incorporates instrumental purpose; what is right is what provides immediate value to the individual and what encourages beneficial reciprocity from another.[xxvii]

Conventional morality, forming stages three and four, encompasses the type of moral reasoning first arising in grade school and continuing through young adulthood. In stage three, one’s reasoning is a function of conformity to a social group. What is right for a person in stage three is “living up to what is expected by people close to you”. . . because of the desire “. . . to be a good person in your own eyes and those of others.”[xxviii] Stage four builds on the external pressure of a social group by adding adherence to a social system. What is right in this stage is fulfilling one’s duty, upholding laws, and contributing to institutions and society. [xxix]

Post-conventional morality forms the final two stages. Stage five moral reasoning operates from a social contract perspective. What is right is what promotes the common good and protects the rights of all involved with impartiality and recognizes there may be a conflict between individual morals and norms or laws. It follows, then, that a person in stage five is more attuned to dilemmas and willing to consider a course of action that may be in opposition to group norms. Finally, in Kohlberg’s sixth stage, called universal ethical principles, what is moral is what is universally applicable, such as fundamental human rights and the dignity of the individual.[xxx] A person operating in this stage of moral reasoning may very well disregard the social contract, seeing themselves as unconstrained by an ineffective system if that system conflicts with internalized universal principles.

Kohlberg concludes that the majority of adults do not advance beyond conventional morality. In short, most applicants seeking to join the ranks of SOF likely think, decide, and act in situations where a moral question exists—perceived or otherwise—based on what individuals and social groups deem acceptable or unacceptable. This is not without its implications for SOF teams, which are themselves a social system.

Robert Kegan’s Theory of the Evolution of Consciousness

In his seminal work, In Over Our Heads, Kegan describes increasingly complex ways the human conscious constructs meaning, with higher orders including and being preferred to the lower.[xxxi] The four orders most relevant to adult life are order two through five. In order two, called the instrumental mind, individuals relate to others as “separate and unique beings,”[xxxii] but one’s own needs maintain primacy.[xxxiii] This order is marked by competition and compromise within social settings, with relationships tending toward the instrumental or transactional, hence the name.[xxxiv] In order three, called the socialized mind, individuals are acutely aware of their feelings and demonstrate mental abstraction by perceiving and considering other’s desires and emotions.[xxxv] Kegan  states that this order is akin to tribalism, where one’s group ideology reigns[xxxvi] and where “other people are experienced as sources of internal validation, orientation, and authority.”[xxxvii] In order four, called the self-authoring mind, individuals assume responsibility for their values and belief systems.[xxxviii] In this order, relationships with others no longer serve as the foundation for one’s identity. Moreover, individuals can see linkages between abstract concepts such as the rule of law and individual rights. Kegan’s final order, the self-transforming mind, is rarely observed in others under the age of forty.[xxxix] In this order, a person demonstrates the ability to see beyond societal constructions and culture and can incorporate commonalities that transcend ideologies and national borders.[xl]

Numerous longitudinal studies conducted by Kegan and others in the field of developmental psychology indicate that nearly two-thirds of adults have not reached the fourth-order of consciousness.[xli] Instead, most adults are conscious of others insofar as they can make use of them (treating people as means rather than ends) or are conscious of others insofar as they form their identity in relation to them. With Kohlberg and Kegan in mind, the ideal SOF candidate should demonstrate post-conventional morality and a self-authoring mind, as both serve as preconditions for adopting and developing a virtue ethics framework. Aristotle, one of the founders of virtue ethics, presupposes that one must first be willing to adopt and train according to a potentially new system of habits. In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle writes, “The virtues, then, come neither by nature nor against nature, but nature gives the capacity for acquiring them, and this is developed by training.”[xlii] Incorporation of Kohlberg and Kegan into SOF selection will assist in highlighting those individuals whose natures are open to the adoption and development of Aristotelian virtue ethics.

An Overview of Aristotelian Virtue Ethics

“. . . the practice of . . . professionals is to make discretionary judgments routinely; those judgments are highly moral in nature; such decisions are better made by professionals of high moral character.”

      —Colonel (Retired) Don Snider[xliii]

Aristotle writes that all designed objects, inanimate and animate, have a specific function they are best suited to accomplish.[xliv] Synthesizing Aristotle and Snider, I submit that the specific function for which SOF is best suited is the application of discretionary moral-ethical judgment[xlv] in the conduct of operations in “hostile, denied, or politically sensitive environments [which] are characterized by one or more of the following elements: [they are] time-sensitive, clandestine, low visibility, [or] conducted with [or] through indigenous forces, [require] regional expertise, and/or a high degree of risk.[xlvi] Though the object (or in this case the collective body of SOF) may suffice in accomplishing a different function from which it was designed, it will be unable to be employed in an excellent manner consistent with its full potential. To illustrate this point, just as a Navy SEAL platoon is not designed to engage in mounted maneuver warfare (e.g., tank vs. tank battle), an Army cavalry platoon is not designed to conduct a hostage rescue. While either force could conceivably swap roles, neither the tank nor the hostage would likely fare as well.

Simplifying by way of analogy, the function of a sword is to cut or pierce. A virtuous sword is one that is balanced, honed, maintains an edge, and ultimately cuts or pierces well. If a sword lacks any of these virtues, we call it a poor sword; it lacks the character—the summation of virtues (or the means)—of a good sword. By extension, SOF application of discretionary moral-ethical judgment in accordance with virtue means doing so with balance, within a honed moral-ethical framework. Moreover, that framework must be able to hold its edge when tested in the presence of a moral-ethical question. Just as the sword best displays its virtue in cutting, SOF exhibit the epitome of proper discretionary moral-ethical judgment when doing so according to a virtue ethics framework. Those SOF personnel that reason and act against virtue (i.e., they reason and act in accordance with vice) lack the character required of military professionals.

Aristotle describes many virtues in Nicomachean Ethics that all should seek to develop. Though he discusses the virtues of honor, justice, even anger, he holds two—courage and temperance—in high esteem.[xlvii] Were SOF to focus only on habituating adherence to these two virtues within the ranks, there would likely exist a sufficient bulwark against moral-ethical lapses. To be virtuous, then, is to moderate our reasoning and actions. It means heading former Secretary of Defense, James Mattis’s call to run the “ethical midfield”[xlviii] and to shy away from the vices of excess and deficiency on the sidelines. Taking courage, for example, the vice of excess is rashness; the vice of deficiency is cowardice. Regarding temperance (self-restraint), the excess is insensibility; the deficiency is self-indulgence.[xlix] Each time a situation exists where the virtue of courage or temperance is hanging in the balance—which is to say nearly every discretional moral-ethical judgment a military leader makes in the conduct of duty—there is an opportunity to reinforce these virtues through habituation.

Finally, Aristotle posits that the virtues can be learned through modeling the behavior of virtuous people (what those in the military might call “leaders of character”), and the virtues are ingrained (made implicit) through habituation of proper reasoning and proper action. Habitually acting out of virtue will likely place one in direct contention with those exercising other ethical frameworks and with those who routinely dispose of moral-ethical considerations altogether. In these cases—especially when circumstances call for moral courage—falling on one’s sword may be the only virtuous option.

Why Aristotelian Virtue Ethics?

“Leaders must prepare their units to fight and adapt under conditions of uncertainty and, during the conduct of operations, must also ensure moral conduct and make critical time-sensitive decisions under pressure.”

—The Army Capstone Concept: Operational Adaptability—Operating Under Conditions of Uncertainty and Complexity in an Era of Persistent Conflict, 2016-2028.[l]

 

Aristotle’s virtue ethics provide SOF personnel flexibility in moral-ethical decision making in ways that deontological (duty or rule-based) ethical systems do not. Furthermore, the character-building inherent in the practice of virtue ethics takes a proactive and preventive approach to moral-ethical breaches. This is because virtue ethics places the locus of control within the actor. In contrast, a deontological approach risks reducing moral-ethical agency by placing the locus of control external to the actor. When faced with a moral-ethical question, the internalized habituated virtue is drawn forth. This implicit adoption of virtuous thinking and acting is superior to deontology’s reactive nature, as deontology requires that one respond to a situation after referencing a set of rules. When under pressure, facing a “critical, time-sensitive decision,”[li] a reactive nature is a liability.

Immanuel Kant, arguably the most influential deontological ethicist, argues that our motivation for action should be bound by duty. Kant maintains that we should obey moral law above all else regardless of the consequences, saying “the moral worth of an action does not lie in the effect expected from it, nor in any principle of action which requires to borrow its motive from this expected effect.”[lii] With Kant, there are no qualifications when it comes to deciding our response; he mandates that we behave according to a moral imperative such as “do not kill” regardless of the circumstances. Given that the military profession is inherently violent, it would seem necessary to violate the moral imperative or to create a subcategory within it such as “do not kill except in self-defense” or “do not kill unless your target is a lawful combatant.” Qualifying a moral imperative adds tension to the moral system. For example, two parties engaged in combat may equally say their actions are in the interest of self-defense. Who then maintains the moral high ground when killing? Kant would undoubtedly take issue with expanding upon the original moral imperative because doing so may undermine the integrity of the moral law. This impracticability of rigid adherence to deontological ethics is one of its most significant criticisms.

In the abstract, dealing with the rigidity of a moral imperative through the incorporation of a subcategory seems reasonable and may even be generally sufficient to maintain good order. For example, it is wrong to violate the speed limit. However, many would agree that if a passenger is suffering a medical emergency, speeding is acceptable; therefore, the possible expanded sub categorical imperative might be “it is wrong to speed unless there is an emergency.” Still, when complex, high-pressure situations call for an expanded categorical imperative (one that likely has not been identified in training nor explicitly codified in an organization’s ethics), the ability for SOF personnel to construct an appropriate exception to the rule is less predictable and therefore full of risk. As a SOF team deployment date nears, the chain of command’s awareness of risk manifests itself on paper.

A commander, realizing too late that the deploying team’s virtue has not been vetted, ponders every possible moral-ethical bump in the road and constructs a pre-deployment “Rules of the Road” memorandum. These legalistic documents place a pylon near every prognosticated moral-ethical pothole, effectively creating rule-based chokepoints. Though well-intended, these memorandums often serve more as a defensive document that leaders wave as evidence of engaged leadership once an individual or team suffers a moral-ethical breach of conduct. The length of such memorandums is likely inversely proportional to the amount of time the signatory invested in training and educating subordinates to conduct themselves within a moral-ethical framework. What is more, burdening teams with legalese violates the very tenants of core doctrine.

In recognition of today’s unconventional conflicts, where adversaries seamlessly float in and out of the civilian population, the Army published The Army Capstone Concept: Operational Adaptability—Operating Under Conditions of Uncertainty and Complexity in an Era of Persistent Conflict. The Army intended for this doctrinal text to compel an institutional-level change in preparation for perceived threats its personnel would face out to the year 2028. USSOCOM leadership and subordinate commands would do well to embrace the following from its pages, “To facilitate the necessary level of adaptation, Army forces empower increasingly lower echelons of command with the capabilities, capacities, authorities, and responsibilities needed to think independently and act decisively, morally, and ethically.”[liii] The best way to empower leaders to act decisively, in harmony with accepted moral principles and institutional ethics, is to educate and train individuals within an inherently adaptive virtue ethics framework.

Consequentialism, commonly referred to as “the ends justify the means” by pragmatists, holds that the outcome of an act provides the basis for judging the act’s rightness or wrongness.[liv] The means, though possibly unsavory, are always subordinate to the rightness of the ends. Clearly, there are certain means which those serving in SOF are unable to employ in realizing the desired ends. For example, the Uniform Code of Military Justice and the International Law of Armed Conflict serve as ethical backstops to an array of means that might otherwise be considered available (e.g., killing an unarmed suspected terrorist to prevent future attacks). Consequentialist thinking risks opening the door to moral-ethical fading, the desensitization to moral-ethical questions. Despite an action being intuitively immoral or unethical, a consequentialist approach may push an actor toward an end that provides more utility than “doing the right thing” in the supposed service of accomplishing the mission. The type of rationalization that allows for a seemingly insignificant rule to be broken because, say, following the rule is supposedly a detriment to unit morale (e.g., enforcing haircut standards and uniform regulations) creates a debt to discipline. This debt risks collection once deployed and increases the likelihood of moral-ethical breaches. When SOF individuals and teams train on the ethical sidelines, supported by a unit culture that tacitly approves acts of indiscipline, we should not be surprised nor expect teams to run operations in the ethical midfield. Detractors will immediately decry the supposed use of an absurd extrapolation. Still, the military has long adhered to the broken-window theory of discipline, in part because doing so guards against consequentialism. Only months ago, Rear Admiral Green, the Commander of all Naval Special Warfare forces, connected the dots between low-level indiscipline and the more extreme ethical breaches which have garnered national attention. In an August 2019 memorandum, he banned the use of unofficial unit patches and demanded subordinate leaders enforce basic grooming standards. These measures are designed to target a root cause of ethical fading—an organization’s tacit approval of indiscipline.[lv]  

This is not to say that consequentialist and deontological constructs do not have their place. Instead, this is to say that service in special operations first requires virtuous actors and virtuous teams. With the virtues serving as the foundation, SOF personnel should then engage in principled but practical consideration of the rules and then consider the most appropriate outcome. Developing virtuous actors will ensure SOF personnel steer toward the ethical midfield by creating options outside of dogmatic adherence to rules and by expelling any immoral and unethical means in pursuit of the ends.

Applying Aristotle to SOF Education and Training

The current SOF ethics education for officers and enlisted service members is insufficient in scope, frequency, and applicability. Discussing deontological, consequentialist, and virtue ethics frameworks during professional military education and engaging in case studies, although a good start, is not enough to impel change at the tactical level. These discrete forays into the academic realm, sprinkled throughout a 20-plus year career, practically ensure that moral-ethical development is viewed as something for the classroom only.

Just as unfortunate, the junior officer(s) leading a SOF team is often years removed from any formal ethical training, yet is expected to serve as the moral-ethical compass for all service members in the organization.[lvi] A point about actual compasses though—they do not lead or make decisions; they only point at an attractive element. These attractive elements may manifest themselves during deployment as the opportunity to misuse funds for personal gain, the longing to remain popular within a team that has blurred the lines between officers and enlisted personnel, or perhaps the desire to execute vigilante, frontier justice on a suspected combatant. How do SOF organizations ensure their junior leaders’ moral compasses do not orient on the wrong element?

Though it is a multifaceted answer, one which includes selecting the right people, another facet must be education and training. Incorporating moral-ethical scenarios into field training and providing feedback during developmental counseling ensures that moral-ethical development will maintain a persistent presence within the unit culture. As it stands, SOF teams are not educated or trained to identify—much less address—moral-ethical questions in a practical setting within a virtue ethics framework. Perhaps the reason for this is that the military tends to train what it can easily measure, such as physical fitness and weapons qualification. 

Many SOF units are required, at a minimum, to test individuals for physical fitness twice every year. Practically every SOF installation or compound features state-of-the-art gyms complete with contracted personal trainers to promote physical excellence within the ranks. Surely SOF leadership can make time for moral-ethical fitness assessments to support excellence in discretionary moral-ethical judgment. Perhaps teams are just expected to rise to the occasion while deployed. Yet, no organization in the military expects its members to simply rise to the level of an expert marksman when at a weapons range. To illustrate the point, units do not conduct a weapons qualification until all personnel revisit, through education and practical exercises, the fundamentals of marksmanship. This is followed by a validation (zeroing) of each weapon’s sights before engaging a target for record. Qualifying on a weapons range is a less demanding feat than correctly addressing a moral-ethical question, and it is less fraught with potentially catastrophic consequences. Why, then, would SOF leaders deploy individuals and teams who have not been formally educated on moral frameworks and whose moral-ethical alignment has not been validated? The cost of doing so is only time; the cost of not doing so? Well, just read the headlines.  

Where there is a moral-ethical shortcoming, there is also a training and education opportunity. Recognizing that so-called small moral-ethical transgressions are actually, “cracks in the SOF foundations,”[lvii] is only a part of the solution; we must also recognize and reward quiet courage and shadowed self-restraint. When individuals step forward and demonstrate moral courage, likely at the cost of expediency and their popularity (and potentially their safety), leaders should pause and recognize these virtues in action. Organizations must ensure that whistleblowers are not alienated by those whose actions were called into question, as courage of this nature is a precious commodity in short supply. These individuals are the ethical circuit breakers which just might save an organization from an ethical inferno.

Conclusion

“[I]ndeed we shall do well to suspect, in philosophy, any doctrine which plumes itself on novelty. Truth changes her garments frequently. . . but under the new habit she remains always the same. In morals we need not expect startling innovations[.]”

    —Will Durant, The Story of Philosophy[lviii]

In an age where newer is often confused for better, suggesting that USSOCOM adopt, educate, and train according to the tenants of a 2,500-year-old text is a tall hill to hike. Still, better to trudge upward with Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics in hand than to continue responding to the gross moral-ethical breaches that continue to dominate news cycles and call into question the very foundation of the professional military ethic—our ability to self-regulate.

If we agree that morals are deeply held, unchanging principles governing right and wrong, it seems necessary to select those individuals who not only exemplify sufficient moral alignment with SOF institutional ethics but who also demonstrate an acceptable capacity for discretionary moral-ethical judgment. With respect to the sword, we should be selecting post-conventional, self-authoring blades willing and able to take an Aristotelian edge. An individual demonstrating post-conventional morality is willing to consider right and wrong largely independent of a proximal social group, reducing the likelihood of unhealthy conformity on a team; likewise, an individual demonstrating a self-authoring mindset is more committed to personal responsibility than personal relationships. This commitment leads to greater moral-ethical agency while reducing the impact of situational factors.

Beyond SOF selection, the hard work of educating and training teams to decide and act in a virtue ethics framework should begin immediately. The good news is, once leaders expose all individuals to the tenants of Aristotelian virtue ethics, no syllabus is required, no online-mandatory training need be developed, and no lunch breaks need be interrupted with discussions of abstract ethical dilemmas. Rather, anywhere and anytime a moral-ethical question arises in the workplace, there exists an educational opportunity. When field-based training lacks a moral-ethical question, a leader can inject one that creates a window for virtuous action without the hindrance of a resource request.

Without so much as defining the term “ethics,” the USSOCOM Comprehensive Review, despite over 20 pages of findings and recommended actions, assessed that USSOCOM does not have a systemic ethics problem.[lix] While there is limited attention paid to SOF assessment and selection, nowhere in the 69-page document is a substantive change to current moral-ethical education or training mentioned, specifically regarding developing excellence in the application of discretionary moral-ethical judgment.[lx] Education and training are major building blocks of unit culture; without addressing these key areas, there can be no systemic solution. Failure to do so all but guarantees another batch of unfortunate headlines followed by increased congressional oversight, leading to another round of policy letters and a comprehensive review which will likely say, according to a January, 2020 “Stars and Stripes” article, that SOF “ethics slips” are largely the product of deploying too much.[lxi] Essentially, the blame is placed on the external factors—the situation—instead of a SOF individual’s faulty moral-ethical foundation.

Every day in SOF units, leaders and subordinates should be asking themselves if the person adjacent to them demonstrates a sufficient capacity for discretionary moral-ethical judgment. Each day is a training opportunity for SOF leaders to improve upon the individual and collective defenses of its moral-ethical fortress. Likewise, each time leaders tacitly permit, approve, or pardon a moral-ethical transgression within the ranks, they weaken the integrity of the moral-ethical framework and damage the cornerstone of accountability within unit culture, ultimately sabotaging the work of the good and rewarding that of the bad. Through the millennia, Aristotle reminds us, “. . . and so with builders and the rest; by building well they will become good builders, and bad builders by building badly.”[lxii] Were he on the House Armed Services Committee, Aristotle might suggest that USSOCOM leadership reflect deeply on the selection, training, and education of its builders, as opposed to sifting through the rubble of failed creations.

Bibliography

The Army Capstone Concept. Operational Adaptability: Operating under Conditions in Uncertainty and Complexity in an Era of Persistent Conflict. Training and Doctrine Command. Accessed November 29, 2019. https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/ a517617.pdf.

Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics. Translated by F. H. Peters. New York: Barnes & Noble Books, 2005.

“Civil Affairs.” Civil Affairs Recruiting. Accessed November 28, 2019. https://goarmy sof.com/CivilAffairs/CArecruiting.html.

Clarke, Richard. “Special Operations Forces Culture and Ethics Comprehensive Review—Letter to the Force.” Accessed January 30, 2020. https://www.socom.mil/Documents/Multi-star-letter-to-the-force-as-of-27-JAN-20.pdf.

Durant, Will. The Story of Civilization: Caesar and Christ. (World Library, 1944). http://www. daniellazar.com/wp-content/uploads/Durant-Christ-and-Civ.pdf.

Durant, Will. The Story of Philosophy. New York: Garden City Publishing Co., Inc., 1938. http://www.rosenfels.org/Durant.pdf.

“Ethics, Morality and Leadership: Snider Dedicates Life to Army Profession.” Association of the United States Army. Accessed November 28, 2019. https://www.ausa.org/articles /snider dedicates-life-army-profession.

Feickert, Andrew. “U.S. Special Operations Forces (SOF): Background and Issues for Congress.” U.S. Congressional Research Service. Accessed November 28, 2019. https://fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RS21048.pdf.

Healy, Patrick. “The Fundamental Attribution Error: How It Affects Your Organization and How to Overcome It-Harvard Business School Online.” Business Insights, June 8, 2017. https://online.hbs.edu/blog/post/the-fundamental-attribution-error.

Kant, Immanuel. Ethical Philosophy: The Complete Texts of Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals, and Metaphysical Principles of Virtue, Part II of The Metaphysics of Morals. Trans. James K. Ellington. Indianapolis: Hackett Pub. Co., 1994.

“Kegan's Theory of the Evolution of Consciousness.” Stanford University: Tomorrow's Professor Postings. Accessed November 29, 2019. https://tomprof.stanford.edu/posting/1110.

Kilner, Pete. “When 'Moral Compasses' Need Calibration.” Association of the United States Army. Accessed November 28, 2019. https://www.ausa.org/articles/moral-compasses.

Kohlberg, Lawrence. Child Psychology and Childhood Education. White Plains, NY: Longman, 1987.

Kristjánsson, Kristján. “An Aristotelian Critique of Situationism.” Philosophy 83, no. 323 (2008): 55-76. www.jstor.org/stable/20185287.

LaPorta, James. “U.S. Special Operations Command Issues Ethics Guidance after ‘Inexcusable and Reprehensible Violations’ by Personnel.” Newsweek. Last modified December 13, 2018. https://www.newsweek.com/us-special-operations-ethics-war-crimes-military-1255843.

Long, Derrick. The Right Soldier for the Right Job: Assessing Complex Military Occupations. Accessed November 29, 2019. https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/3454.pdf.

Martinez, Luis. “Special Operations Command Orders Comprehensive Ethics Review Following Recent Scandals.” ABC News. Last modified August 12, 2019. https://abcnews.go.com /Politics/special-operations-command-orders-comprehensive-ethics-review recent/story ?id=64928932.

Mattis, James. “Ethical Standards for All Hands.” Accessed November 29, 2019. https://dod.de fense.gov/ Portals/1/Documents/pubs/Ethical-Standards-for-All-Hands-SecDef-04-Aug-17.pdf.

McIntyre, Cindy. “Army Special Forces: an inside Look at the Elite Group's Capabilities.” Last modified August 15, 2017. https://www.army.mil/article/192302/ army_special_forces_ an_inside_look_at_the_elite_groups_capabilities.

Myers, Meghann. “Former Army Green Berets Sentenced in Colombian Cocaine Smuggling Plot.” Army Times. Last modified May 1, 2019. https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/05/01/former-army-green-berets-sentenced-in-colombian-cocaine-smuggling-plot/.

Myers, Meghann. “SOCOM Boss Calls for Another Ethics Review.” Military Times. Military Times. Last modified August 13, 2019. https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2019/08/12/socom-boss-calls-for-another-ethics-review/.

Rempfer, Kyle. “JSOC Deputy Tapped to Lead Division-Level 1st Special Forces Command during Modernization Period.” Army Times. Last modified October 24, 2019. https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/10/24/jsoc-deputy-tapped-to-lead-division-level-1st-special-forces-command-during-modernization-period/.

“Review Finds Heavy Use of Commando Forces Led to Ethics Slip.” Stars and Stripes, January 28, 2020. https://www.stripes.com/news/us/review-finds-heavy-use-of-commando-forces-led-to-ethics-slip-1.616644.

Robert, Kegan. “RSA 21st Century Enlightenment.” RSA 21st Century Enlightenment. Accessed November 28, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BoasM4cCHBc.

Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. “Consequentialism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Stanford University, June 3, 2019. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consequentialism/.

Smith, Stewart. “A Look at Special Operations Command (SOCOM) Creeds, Codes and Mottos.” The Balance Careers. Last modified January 6, 2019. https://www.thebalance careers.com/creed-and-mottos-of-the-special-operations-command-socom-4108507.

Snider, Don. “Renewing the Motivational Power of the Army’s Professional Ethic.” The U.S. Army Quarterly Parameters 44, no. 3 (2014): 7–11. https://www.hsdl.org/?abstract&did= 759712.

Szoldra, Paul. “Top Navy SEAL: 'We Have a Problem'.” Task & Purpose. Last modified August 1, 2019. https://taskandpurpose.com/seal-admiral-problem.

Thomas, Raymond. “Ethics and Our SOF Culture 7 A Call To Action SOCOM: General Raymond Thomas.” SOFX. Last modified July 18, 2019. https://www.sofx.com/2018/ 12/13/ethics-and-our-sof-culture-7-a-call-to-action-socom-general-raymond-thomas/.

“United States Special Operations Command Comprehensive Review.” January 23, 2020. https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%3AUS%3Ab74eacf5-160d-4dac-afca-ecde4c0ecaaf.

Upton, Candace L. “Virtue Ethics and Moral Psychology: The Situationism Debate.” The Journal of Ethics 13, no. 2-3 (2009): 103–15. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10892-009-9054-2.

Violato, Claudio. “Interactionism in Psychology and Education: A New Paradigm or a Source of Confusion?” The Journal of Educational Thought 22, no. 1 (April 1988): 4–20. https:// www.jstor.org/stable/23768443.

End Notes


     [i]. Raymond Thomas, “Ethics and Our SOF Culture 7 A Call To Action SOCOM: General Raymond Thomas,” SOFX, last modified July 18, 2019, https://www.sofx.com/2018/12/13/ethics-and-our-sof-culture-7-a-call-to-action-socom-general-raymond-thomas/.

     [ii]. Paul Szoldra, “Top Navy SEAL: 'We Have a Problem',” Task & Purpose, last modified August 1, 2019, https://taskandpurpose.com/seal-admiral-problem.

     3. Richard Clarke, “Special Operations Forces Culture and Ethics Comprehensive Review—Letter to the Force,” accessed January 30, 2020, https://www.socom.mil/Documents/Multi-star-letter-to-the-force-as-of-27-JAN-20.pdf.

     [iv]. Will Durant, The Story of Civilization: Caesar and Christ (World Library, 1944), http://www.daniellazar. com/wp-content/uploads/Durant-Christ-and-Civ.pdf, 803.

     [v]. The terms moral and ethical are often substituted for one another despite certain nuances in meaning. In this paper, I consider that a moral principle refers to a deeply held internal belief about right and wrong that governs thoughts and behavior and is resistant to change, e.g., killing is wrong. An ethical principle refers to a societally or organizationally-constructed external rule governing behavior and varies depending on the societal and organizational setting. Though often informed by moral principles, an ethical principle may qualify the moral principle in the service of the societal or organizational goals, e.g., while killing is generally considered a moral breach, killing in the service of an approved military objective is considered ethical within the military profession. 

     [vi]. Kyle Rempfer, “JSOC Deputy Tapped to Lead Division-Level 1st Special Forces Command during Modernization Period,” Army Times, last modified October 24, 2019, https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/10/24/jsoc-deputy-tapped-to-lead-division-level-1st-special-forces-command-during-modernization-period/.

     [vii]. Andrew Feickert, “U.S. Special Operations Forces (SOF): Background and Issues for Congress,” U.S. Congressional Research Service, accessed November 28, 2019, https://fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RS21048.pdf.

     [viii]. Cindy McIntyre, “Army Special Forces: an inside Look at the Elite Group's Capabilities,” last modified August 15, 2017, https://www.army.mil/article/192302/army_special_forces_an_inside_look_at_the_elite_groups_ capabilities.

     [ix]. Stewart Smith, “A Look at Special Operations Command (SOCOM) Creeds, Codes and Mottos,” The Balance Careers, last modified January 6, 2019, https://www.thebalancecareers.com/creed-and-mottos-of-the-special-operations-command-socom-4108507.

     [x]. “Civil Affairs,” Civil Affairs Recruiting, accessed November 28, 2019, https://goarmysof.com/CivilAffairs/CA recruiting.html.

     [xi]. Meghann Myers, “Former Army Green Berets Sentenced in Colombian Cocaine Smuggling Plot,” Army Times, last modified May 1, 2019, https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/05/01/former-army-green-berets-sentenced-in-colombian-cocaine-smuggling-plot/.

     [xii]. Meghann Myers, “SOCOM Boss Calls for Another Ethics Review,” Military Times, last modified August 13, 2019, https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2019/08/12/socom-boss-calls-for-another-ethics-review/.

     [xiii]. Andrew Feickert, “U.S. Special Operations Forces (SOF): Background and Issues for Congress”, 8.

     [xiv]. Luis Martinez, “Special Operations Command Orders Comprehensive Ethics Review Following Recent Scandals,” ABC News, last modified August 12, 2019, https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/special-operations-command-orders-comprehensive-ethics-review-recent/story?id=64928932.

     [xv]. “United States Special Operations Command Comprehensive Review,” January 23, 2020. https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%3AUS%3Ab74eacf5-160d-4dac-afca-ecde4c0ecaaf.

     [xvi]. James LaPorta, “U.S. Special Operations Command Issues Ethics Guidance after ‘Inexcusable and Reprehensible Violations’ by Personnel,” Newsweek, last modified December 13, 2018, https://www.newsweek. com/us-special-operations-ethics-war-crimes-military-1255843.

     [xvii]. Patrick Healy, “The Fundamental Attribution Error: How It Affects Your Organization and How to Overcome It-Harvard Business School Online,” Business Insights, June 8, 2017, https://online.hbs.edu/blog/post/the-fundamental-attribution-error.

     [xviii]. Kristján Kristjánsson, “An Aristotelian Critique of Situationism,” Philosophy 83, no. 323 (2008): 58, www.jstor.org/stable/20185287.

     [xix]. Candace L. Upton, “Virtue Ethics and Moral Psychology: The Situationism Debate,” The Journal of Ethics 13, no. 2-3 (2009): 104, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10892-009-9054-2.

     [xx]. Gilbert Harman, “No Character or Personality,” accessed November 28, 2019, https://pdfs.semanticscholar. org/c984/016139dca210b829a1ba2e3ef1fde5279007.pdf, 7.

     [xxi]. Claudio Violato, “Interactionism in Psychology and Education: A New Paradigm or a Source of Confusion?,” The Journal of Educational Thought 22, no. 1 (April 1988): 4, https://www.jstor.org/stable/23768443.

     [xxii]. Ibid.

     [xxiii]. “Ethics, Morality and Leadership: Snider Dedicates Life to Army Profession.” Association of the United States Army, accessed November 28, 2019, https://www.ausa.org/articles/snider-dedicates-life-army-profession.

     [xxiv]. Derrick Long, “The Right Soldier for the Right Job: Assessing Complex Military Occupations,” accessed November 29, 2019, https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/ 3454.pdf.

     [xxv]. Lawrence Kohlberg, Child Psychology and Childhood Education (New York: Longman, 1987), 14.

     [xxvi]. Ibid., 284-285.

     [xxvii]. Ibid. 

     [xxviii]. Ibid.

     [xxix]. Ibid.

     [xxx]. Ibid., 286.

     [xxxi]. “Kegan's Theory of the Evolution of Consciousness,” Stanford University: Tomorrow's Professor Postings, accessed November 29, 2019, https://tomprof.stanford.edu/posting/1110.

      [xxxii]. Ibid.

     [xxxiii]. Ibid.

     [xxxiv]. Ibid.

     [xxxv]. Ibid.

     [xxxvi]. Robert Kegan, “RSA 21st Century Enlightenment,” RSA 21st Century Enlightenment, accessed November 28, 2019, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BoasM4cCHBc.

     [xxxvii]. “Kegan's Theory of the Evolution of Consciousness” Stanford University: Tomorrow's Professor Postings, accessed November 29, 2019, https://tomprof.stanford.edu/posting/1110.

     [xxxviii]. Ibid.

     [xxxix]. Ibid.

     [xl]. Ibid.

     [xli]. Ibid.   

     [xlii]. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, trans. by F. H. Peters (New York: Barnes & Noble Books, 2005), 23. 

     [xliii]. Don Snider, “Renewing the Motivational Power of the Army’s Professional Ethic,” The U.S. Army Quarterly Parameters 44, no. 3 (2014): 8, https://www.hsdl.org/?abstract&did=759712.

     [xliv]. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, 10.

     [xlv]. Don Snider, “Renewing the Motivational Power of the Army’s Professional Ethic,” The U.S. Army Quarterly Parameters 44, no. 3 (2014): 8, https://www.hsdl.org/?abstract&did=759712.

     [xlvi]. Andrew Feickert, “U.S. Special Operations Forces (SOF): Background and Issues for Congress,” U.S. Congressional Research Service, accessed November 28, 2019, https://fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RS21048.pdf.

     [xlvii]. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, 58-64.

     48. James Mattis, “Ethical Standards for All Hands,” accessed November 29, 2019, https://dod.defense.gov/ Portals/1/Documents/pubs/Ethical-Standards-for-All-Hands-SecDef-04-Aug-17.pdf.

     [xlix]. Ibid., 55, 59.

     [li]. Ibid. 

     [lii]. Immanuel Kant, Ethical Philosophy: The Complete Texts of Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals, and Metaphysical Principles of Virtue, Part II of The Metaphysics of Morals trans. James. W. Ellington (Indianapolis: Hackett Pub. Co., 1994), 13.

     [liii]. The Army Capstone Concept, Operational Adaptability: Operating under Conditions in Uncertainty and Complexity in an Era of Persistent Conflict, Training and Doctrine Command, accessed November 29, 2019, https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a517617.pdf.

     [liv]. Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, “Consequentialism,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University, June 3, 2019, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consequentialism/.

     [lv]. Paul Szoldra, “Top Navy SEAL: 'We Have a Problem',” Task & Purpose, las modified August 1, 2019, https://taskandpurpose.com/seal-admiral-problem.

     [lvi]. Pete Kilner, “When 'Moral Compasses' Need Calibration,” Association of the United States Army, accessed November 28, 2019, https://www.ausa.org/articles/moral-compasses.

     [lvii]. “United States Special Operations Command Comprehensive Review,” January 23, 2020. https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%3AUS%3Ab74eacf5-160d-4dac-afca-ecde4c0ecaaf.

     [lviii]. Will Durant, The Story of Philosophy (New York: Garden City Publishing Co., Inc., 1938), http://www. rosenfels.org/Durant.pdf, 49.

     [lix]. “United States Special Operations Command Comprehensive Review,” January 23, 2020. https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%3AUS%3Ab74eacf5-160d-4dac-afca-ecde4c0ecaaf.

     [lx]. Ibid.

     [lxi]. “Review Finds Heavy Use of Commando Forces Led to Ethics Slip.” Stars and Stripes, January 28, 2020. https://www.stripes.com/news/us/review-finds-heavy-use-of-commando-forces-led-to-ethics-slip-1.616644.

     [lxii]. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, 23.

About the Author(s)

Captain Benjamin Ordiway is a Civil Affairs Officer in the 92nd Civil Affairs Battalion. He served as the Team Commander of the Civil-Military Support Element, U.S. Embassy Sarajevo, in Bosnia & Herzegovina and has also conducted Civil Affairs Operations in Poland and Serbia. He enlisted as a Cavalry Scout in the Army in 2004 and received his commission as an Armor Officer from the United States Military Academy in 2012. Captain Ordiway is slated to teach philosophy at the United States Military Academy beginning in 2022.

Comments

Avaebrahim28

Tue, 08/02/2022 - 8:57am

Amazon provides unlimited streaming of movies and TV episodes for paid or free trial members to watch amazon prime video on any device you always need to register the device on the Amazon Prime video using amazon.com/mytv. Users can also rent movies or TV shows if they are not prime members. Amazon My TV is a new product that will allow users to watch all of the great shows, movies, and series from Amazon in crystal clear quality on their TV. For more information and latest updates visit our site.

Avaebrahim28

Tue, 08/02/2022 - 8:57am

Disney plus has millions of users in the United States alone and now it is gaining popularity worldwide at a very steady rate. If you are new to Disney plus services and want to stream with it, then the first step is to create your Disney plus account at disneyplus.com/begin and then enter an 8-digit Disney plus activation code to get started with it. For more information and latest updates about disney plus click our below links and visit our disney plus sites.

disneyplus.com/begin

disneyplus.com/begin

Disneyplus.com/begin

disneyplus.com/begin

 

elliotsmith951

Tue, 08/02/2022 - 4:45am

We abc homework help focus a lot of our energy on providing professional help, and we hire the best specific writers. Writing services make it easy to pay to do my computer science homework help. What is the point of asking such services for quality academic help? When you request help from such services, you will discover that it will take several minutes. You are required to fill out an order form and process the payment. The more information you provide, the bigger the chance that finished product will be what you’re looking for at abc homework help.

elliotsmith951

Tue, 08/02/2022 - 4:43am

I am Elliot Smith. I am an academic writer and editor associated with abc homework help for a decade. Abc homework help is a leading plagiarism free homework writing company. We provide customized homework help service. We are leading the market for more than a decade now and have acquired the name of being the best academic help service for our comprehensive services at pocket-friendly rates.

Getposttop

Mon, 08/01/2022 - 8:26am

A DeFi wallet is a non-custodial wallet that stores your cryptocurrency assets. They are non-custodial, meaning only those with the seed phrase or private key (the equivalent of a password) can access your funds. Governments cannot, for instance, freeze the account – although they might be able to order a token issuer to freeze assets sent to exchanges or render some assets obsolete.
Some of the key attractions of DeFi for many consumers are:
It eliminates the fees that banks and other financial companies charge for using their services.
You hold your money in a secure digital wallet instead of keeping it in a bank.
Anyone with an internet connection can use it without needing approval.
You can transfer funds in seconds and minutes.

Getposttop

Mon, 08/01/2022 - 8:26am

Best Games to Stream on Twitch 2022.With thousands of games to stream on Twitch, it can be difficult to narrow down what you should play. This guide will cover 10 good options as well as give you strategies in looking at other games.
Live streaming is practically a 24/7 business in itself. In fact, people literally make a living by sharing their gaming sessions with a live audience. Sites like Twitch, an online tool to live stream anything from cooking shows to video games, have gone from online novelties to serious indicators of market success.
 

Getposttop

Mon, 08/01/2022 - 8:25am

Everybody knowing What is an ERP System and Why is it Important for Your Company?Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) is business management software that allows an organization to leverage a suite of integrated applications. ERP systems streamline and automate processes, creating a leaner, more accurate and efficient operation. ERP provides complete visibility into core business processes. Enterprise Resource Planning platforms, like BlueCherry ERP, optimize systems through superior resource tracking and reporting, database management and data sharing and overall improved information systems. ERP systems can allow your business to expand without the addition of IT or staffing costs.
 

starzscom2624

Fri, 07/29/2022 - 3:41am

It is easy to access, play, move forward and rewind movies with no interruptions. It offers shows that are from Viacom including Nickelodeon, MTV, VH1, CBS, and Comedy Central You'll get all the information about Disney plus which includes how much it will cost, the shows you can stream there, and so on. Activate Disney plus on your device via Disneyplus.com/begin. Disneyplus has millions of druggies in the United States alone and now it's gaining fashionability each over the world at a veritably steadyrate.However, also the first step is to produce your disney plus account at disneyplus, If you're new at disney plus services and want to stream withit. Disneyplus.com/begin and also enter 8- number disney plus activation law to get started with it. Like other streaming services like Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney also allows you to stream original content on different bias SmartTV, Tablets, Mobile Phone, Computer, and more. Disney plus begins offering an on- demand streaming service with over 74 million druggies at present. When comparing Disney plus subscription freights against other streaming services, you ’ll be pleased to learn that it's only$ 7 per month or roughly.$ 70/ time. If you ’re interested in subscribing up for Disneyplus.com/begin, there are a many effects you need to do. You'll first need to produce an Account. After creating an account, you'll be suitable to start watching television and pictures. Before you can produce an Account, you'll need to choose the plan that you prefer. You have two options the yearly or periodic plan.$6.99/ month and$69.99/ time are the prices for the yearly plan. You can choose to start with the yearly plan, and also switch to the periodic plan latterly. After you have decided on the plan that you like, you can produce an account. You'll need to enter some introductory information similar as your name and dispatch address. A word will also be needed. After creating your account, you'll be suitable to start watching television shows andmovies. Disneyplus.com/begin offers a free 7- day trial. After you ’ve inked to disneyplus.com morning, you're suitable to download the videotape content to play them offline in the future. You can also use the login details to subscribe in to your account on another device. Disney Plus is really one of the most popular streaming platforms across the world. There are tons of Disney Plus druggies who reported to have entered a communication, prompting them tovisit Disneyplus.com/begin and enter an 8- number law. 
 

starzscom2624

Wed, 07/27/2022 - 5:25am

The main activation of STARZ You can complete the main activation process from your computer. Just visit the official website of Starz or go through Starz.com/activate. After that sign-up with a valid email ID.

Visiting the peacocktv.com/tv, a code will be available for peacocktv com tv activation. This Peacocktv.com/tv will enable your access to peacocktv com and you will be able to watch different series online and NBC TV shows. Peacock Streaming was founded by NBC Universal. 

Owned by MGM, it is a 24-hour premium TV network. It’s made up of the flagship Epix and Epix Drive-In channels, offering a total of four premium, ad-free, pay TV channels and on-demand services. Epix.com/devices was also among the first legacy cable channels to offer its library online, and it has adapted to that model well. 

Start the Showtime Anytime app on your Smart TV. Login to your Showtime Anytime account. Select ‘Play’ or select ‘Activate’ from the Settings menu. An activation code appears on your screen. Now, visit Showtime anytime/activate using your web browser. Enter the code and press ‘Submit’. Navigate to the Showtime Anytime channel on Apple TV. Choose a program to watch and press Play” or “Activate.

 

rokuhelps

Wed, 07/20/2022 - 7:26am

Try clearing your browser's cookie and cache. Shut down the browser completely and open it again, and then go to the Sephora website. If you have any problems, please send me or any other mod an email so that we can examine the issue further for you.play.google.com/redeem

rokuhelps

Wed, 07/20/2022 - 6:53am

If you've not received an Beauty Insider card from the Sephora retail store and you're not a member, you're not eligible for an Beauty Insider number. The number is on the card. If you have signed up for Beauty Insider online & have not ever visited a stores, then you don't have an account.
sephora gift card balance | google play redeem code | apple gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | vanilla gift card balance

rokuhelps

Wed, 07/20/2022 - 6:52am

If you've not received an Beauty Insider card from the Sephora retail store and you're not a member, you're not eligible for an Beauty Insider number. The number is on the card. If you have signed up for Beauty Insider online & have not ever visited a stores, then you don't have an account.
sephora gift card balance | google play redeem code | apple gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | vanilla gift card balance | amazon.com/code | amazon.com/code | amex gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | amazon.com/code | lowe's gift card balance | best buy gift card balance | paypal login | amazon prime login | google play redeem code | google play redeem code | vanilla gift card balance | twitch.tv/activate |

rokuhelps

Wed, 07/20/2022 - 6:50am


If you've not received an Beauty Insider card from the Sephora retail store and you're not a member, you're not eligible for an Beauty Insider number. The number is on the card. If you have signed up for Beauty Insider online & have not ever visited a stores, then you don't have an account.
sephora gift card balance | google play redeem code | apple gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | vanilla gift card balance | amazon.com/code | amazon.com/code | amex gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | amazon.com/code | lowe's gift card balance | best buy gift card balance | paypal login | amazon prime login | google play redeem code | google play redeem code | vanilla gift card balance | twitch.tv/activate |

garminnuvi

Sat, 07/09/2022 - 3:11am

Donation Card worth expires two years following date of (1 ) ) card issuance, or (2) last activity on Google Play stored-value account where the card has been redeemed, whichever is later.
play.google.com/redeem | apple gift card balance | vanilla gift card balance | amazon.com/code | amazon.com/code | amex gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | amazon.com/code | lowe's gift card balance | best buy gift card balance | paypal login | amazon prime login | google play redeem code | google play redeem code | sephora gift card balance

garminnuvi

Sat, 07/09/2022 - 3:10am


Donation Card worth expires two years following date of (1 ) ) card issuance, or (2) last activity on Google Play stored-value account where the card has been redeemed, whichever is later.

play.google.com/redeem | apple gift card balance | vanilla gift card balance | amazon.com/code | amazon.com/code | amex gift card balance | play.google.com/redeem | amazon.com/code | lowe's gift card balance | best buy gift card balance | paypal login | amazon prime login | google play redeem code | google play redeem code | sephora gift card balance

Jonsalice9

Sat, 02/19/2022 - 4:33am

Connect Disney Plus on your device at Disney Plus is one of the most popular streaming services in the world. You can find a full list of Disney classics as well as your favorite new Disney movies. disneyplus.com/begincode, which is also a subset of Hotstar, is an example of Hotstar. Disney Hotstar offers a variety of TV shows, movies, and news, as well as sports. It is also famous for its video streaming software.

Jonsalice9

Sat, 02/19/2022 - 4:32am

Electric wheelchairs are useful for people who are unable to maneuver a manual wheelchair or who may need to use a wheelchair for distances or terrain that would be tiring in a manual wheelchair. They can also be used by disabled and active people with cardiovascular and fatigue-related diseases or elderly and geriatric people. Buy Foldable Lightweight buy electric wheelchair Motorized The KosmoCare electric or motorized wheelchair is a buy electric wheelchair that can be propelled by means of a battery-powered electric motor.Electric wheelchairs are useful for people who are unable to maneuver a manual wheelchair or who may need to use a wheelchair for distances or terrain that would be tiring in a manual wheelchair. They can also be used by disabled and active people with cardiovascular and fatigue-related diseases or elderly and geriatric people. Buy Foldable Lightweight Electric Wheelchairs Motorized The KosmoCare electric or motorized wheelchair is a buy electric wheelchair that can be propelled by means of a battery-powered electric motor.

selena142

Sat, 02/19/2022 - 2:03am


Pay-TV services allow the subscribers to watch the Fox News channel on different devices that includes streaming devices,Foxnews.com/connect Smart TV, Xfinity, satellite providers, and more. You need to enter the activation code at foxnews.com/connect and then you will be able to access Fox News on your device. In this post, we will discuss the complete process of activation and many other facts about Fox News.
 

selena142

Sat, 02/19/2022 - 2:02am

Disney Plus costs $8 a month or $80 per year in the US. With a subscription,disneyplus.com/begin you get ad-free access to all of the service's streaming titles. Disney Plus does not currently offer a free trial.There's also an option to buy a bundled package with Hulu and ESPN+, which costs $14 a month for all three services. Individually, ESPN+ and the ad-supported version of  Hulu each cost $7 a month. Subscribing to the bundle saves you about $8 a month.The Disney bundle is also automatically included if you subscribe to any of Hulu's live TV plans. Hulu + Live TV offers access to over 75 channels. Hulu (with ads) + Live TV with Disney Plus and ESPN Plus costs $70 a month. 
 

khansajjad5632

Fri, 02/18/2022 - 6:51am

Yes! You can watch Foxnews.com/connect Channel without a cable or satellite TV subscription. You can watch it live, just as if you were a cable subscriber. All you need is a streaming device like a Roku and a streaming service that carries The Fox News Channel Fox News Channel on Roku comes with most of the News content from the cable version of it. It also has many episodes of many popular shows from the channel if you are a subscriber to the pay TV service.The free content includes the Latest News videos, Top Stories, Primetime Highlights.
 

khansajjad5632

Fri, 02/18/2022 - 6:50am

Launch the Disney+ app and select Log in. Visit disnyeplus.com/start on a computer or mobile device. Enter the 8-digit code you see on your TV and select Continue. Enter your Disney+ login credentials to start streaming.Make sure the device is compatible with Disney Plus, and if it is, restart it. Check for driver and system updates, and if all else fails, reinstall the app. If possible, try using Disney Plus on another device Sign out of your streaming device, whether it is a mobile device or any other device, and restart it . 
 

Avaebrahim28

Fri, 02/18/2022 - 2:39am

Disney Plus is one of the most popular streaming services in the world. You can find a complete list of Disney classics as well as your new favorite Disney films. Disneyplus.com/begin - is one of the most popular streaming services in the world right now. With the entire catalogue of Disney classics available, plus new favorites like Hamilton and exclusives like Muppets Now, it’s not hard to see why. But when it comes to technology, sometimes you need a little help to get going. One of the issues people are seeing now is a message prompt telling them to go to Disneyplus.com/start or disneyplus.com/begincode. Here is what to do if you see that message on your screen.
 

Avaebrahim28

Fri, 02/18/2022 - 2:38am

There are a lot of reasons why you should consider an electric wheelchairs. The most important reason is that they are more comfortable than manual wheelchairs. You can go up and downstairs, over bumps, and even go over long distances. There are about 1.3 million people in the US who need to use a wheelchair regularly. Good quality wheelchairs are designed for comfort and include suspension, choice of wheels, changeable cushions and adjustable footrest positions. If you want to buy electric wheelchair, consider visiting our official website. 

aaron6987

Wed, 01/19/2022 - 6:08am

Open the browser and enter Microsoft365.com/setup in the URL bar and press Enter. Click the blue sign-in button and enter your credentials to sign in with your Microsoft account. You can use any account associated with any Microsoft service like XBOX, Skype, or Windows. However, if you are new to Office, click Create New Account to create a free account with Microsoft. Enter your 25 alphanumeric product codes or enter the required fields and click Next. On the Account page, click the Install Office button on the right. side of the window. This will open another page.

aaron6987

Wed, 01/19/2022 - 2:42am

On the Account page, click the Install Office button on the right. side of the window. This will open another page. This will open a pop-up window, click Install to start the download. Now depending on the browser you are using, save the downloaded installer and run it. Once the installer is downloaded, the installation will begin. Wait for it to finish. It will take a few minutes. Once the installation is complete,<a href="https://micro365softsetup.com">microsoft365.com/setup</a> a screen with animation and a close button will be displayed. Click Close and run the Office applications. Enables you to create, collaborate, and innovate with a host of top-notch messaging, calendaring and apps that you can access anywhere, anytime, and on any device.

 

aaron6987

Sat, 01/15/2022 - 7:13am

To begin the network setup process, you need to turn on the printer by pressing the power button. The power light should be stable and solid green. Now press the Menu button and the Network Settings screen will be displayed. Here you will see separate options for establishing a connection. Select the Wireless LAN Settings option and a pop-up window will appear on your printer screen. Press OK. Choose the SSID Settings option and then select Access Point. Select your preferred network name and enter the Wifi security key correctly. Wait until the printer display shows Connected. ij.start.canon

aaron6987

Sat, 01/15/2022 - 7:12am

Canon IJ Installation Process - Steps to Connect to IJ Starting Canon In this article,ij.start.cannon we have explained the Canon printer installation process through Canon ij installation method. We have explained the process of setting up wired and wireless connections for Windows and Mac operating systems. Basic Prerequisites Before Setting Up the Canon Printer Always have your printer model number ready before you begin the setup process. Make sure your device has enough storage space to install the driver. Make sure the printer is properly plugged into the power outlet.

Avaebrahim28

Thu, 01/13/2022 - 4:43am

Plex is an amazing app with which you can easily manage the media storage and can easily access it from multiple devices. Nowadays, everyone has different choices of TV choices, movies and other entertainment shows that make it too difficult to manage these files. plex tv link TV is a component of the Plex media center suite, a convenient subscription service that lets you stream your media from anywhere. In addition to Plex live TV broadcasts, users can also stream a curated collection of web shows and news broadcasts. plex.tv/link Media Server is a digital media player and organizational tool that allows you to access the music, pictures, and videos stored on one computer with any other computer or compatible mobile device. Plex tv link gives you one place to find and access all the media that matters to you.

Avaebrahim28

Thu, 01/13/2022 - 4:41am

Canon ij.setup is an easiest and quick way which provides a source to connect your printer with other device like windows, Mac  or iPhone. Furthermore, Ij.start.canon is the official online support site of Canon. It offers products’ online manuals, download and installation steps for printer and scanner setup, and more. At ij.start.cannon, you can easily learn to set up a Canon printer or scanner manually without any expert’s help. Read the points on our site for the complete setup process of your Canon printer or scanner.
 

jisoo142

Wed, 01/12/2022 - 5:41am

Canon TR4520 Wireless Office All-In-One Printer make your work easier even when overseeing reports.It combines four main features, they are print,Scan,copy,and fax.ij.start.canon setup The printer keeps running with the shading based and shade ink structure that gives a most over the top focuses of 4800×1200 dpi.It has a print speed of 8.8ipm for dull ink prints and 4.4ipm for shading prints.

jisoo142

Wed, 01/12/2022 - 5:40am

In the address bar type ij.start.canon setup and then, click enter. You will now be taken to the home page of the website. On the home page, you will see tabs for various procedures. You have to click on the “Set Up” icon. When you click on it you are taken to a new window.

sujain6634

Wed, 01/12/2022 - 2:26am

There are scenarios when ij.start.cannon does not open on your device because of some basic issues. When you are stuck while accessing the web page, firstly monitor your internet connection status. If your Wifi is providing better signals, verify the version of the web browser which you are presently using. Also, the web browser must be safe, error-free, and does not include unwanted or unnecessary files. Further, check that the web address you are entering is absolutely correct otherwise your several attempts will not launch the setup page. These quick troubleshooting steps will undoubtedly fix your issue.

sujain6634

Wed, 01/12/2022 - 2:25am

Canon India Pvt. Ltd. is the sales and marketing subsidiary of Canon Inc., a world leader in imaging technologies. Set up in 1997, Canon India markets a comprehensive range of sophisticated contemporary digital imaging products and solutions in India. In sync with its corporate tagline- ‘Delighting You Always’, reinforced by world-class technology,  ij.start.canon setup offers an extended product portfolio, including Digital Production Printers, Large Format Printers, Commercial Printers, Multi-Functional Devices, Managed Document Services, Inkjet & Laser Printers, Document and Cheque Scanners, Digital Cameras, DSLRs, Mirrorless cameras, Cinematic Imaging Products, Surveillance cameras and Medical Imaging products catering to the multiple market segments of consumer, SME, B2B, Commercial, Government & PSUs.
 

alisahwilson

Mon, 12/20/2021 - 7:05am

An assignment paper is a means of evaluating the academic aptitude of the candidates, and online assignments help cheap providers must be able to meet all standards for assignment assistance. The team is made up of highly qualified and devoted topic experts who provide customers with Allassignmenthelp.co.uk services of the highest quality.

davidwalker23

Tue, 12/14/2021 - 12:52am

ij.start canon is a platform for getting the canon printer driver . canonij printer provides an answer for all type of canon printer problems by which you can undoubtedly figure out how to set up from ij.start.canon and improve insight. Go through the easiest way to set up an IJ Canon printer. Canon IJ Setup process takes a few minutes in device installation and software installation. 

 

 

Tomcook280

Sat, 11/27/2021 - 12:13am

The setup process for every Canon model is almost similar, however the download through http //ij.start.cannon or https //ij.start.cannon and  installation process may differ.This model supports Laptop, PC, and mobile printing, including windows and mac both operating systems .Go through ij.start.canon/ts3122 and download the latest full driver & software package for PIXMA TS3122. Let’s start with your Canon printer model setup  ij.start canon is the manufacturer site to download Canon printer drivers. Install and set up Canon Printer from ij.start.canon follow the instructions shown below.

 

rositarosie

Fri, 10/22/2021 - 2:13am

finleyjordon3455

Wed, 10/20/2021 - 1:32am

Microsoft 365 is based on a subscription model, which ensures that users must pay to use Microsoft 365’s services. Microsoft 365 all-time helps you to keep your product up to date while Microsoft updates it. 

Camps.intuit.com  |  Camps.intuit.com  | microsoft365.com/setup

Canon Pixma MG 2522 is an all-in-one inkjet printer equipped with multifunctional features like printer, scanner, and copier. 

Canon.com/ijsetup/mg2522Canon.com/ijsetup mg2522


 

AllenWalter

Fri, 09/24/2021 - 7:31am

We are committed to providing our clients with exceptional solutions while offering web design and development services, graphic design services, organic SEO services, social media services, digital marketing services, server management services and Graphic Design Company in USA.